Get started free →
← All posts
October 31, 2026

56 Canadian Income Tickers, One Scale: The Highest Yields Score Lowest

What we looked at

DivSight scores every fund and stock it covers on one 100-point scale and publishes a BUY, HOLD or SELL. As of our October 31 batch that's 56 tickers. Twenty-eight are funds: 21 covered-call or enhanced-yield, six passive Canadian dividend index funds, and one plain bank index fund we keep as a control. Twenty-eight are stocks: 20 large Canadian blue chips, seven REITs and a split-share corporation. Every number below comes from our research page, which anyone can open and sort.

Two facts about how the scale treats yield, up front. On funds, yield earns no points. The five fund factors are NAV erosion, distribution coverage, expense ratio, size and payment consistency. Yield appears only as the divisor in coverage and in one fee test that can block a BUY but can't create one. On stocks it's the other way round: yield still earns up to 15 points out of 100, and more yield earns more. So if the scale were quietly rewarding yield, the stocks are where you'd expect to see it.

The question is the one from our VDY comparison, run across everything at once. Line yield up against score and see what's there.

What the table says

Start with the blunt version.

The ten highest-yielding tickers average a score of 57. The ten lowest-yielding average 77.5. The median across all 53 is 65.

Among funds the split is cleaner still. The five highest-yielding funds are all covered-call or enhanced-yield products, all rated HOLD, and they average 57. The five lowest-yielding are all passive index funds, VDY, ZDV and ZEB among them, all rated BUY, averaging 87.

To put one number on it, use a rank correlation: line everything up by yield, line it up again by score, and compare the two orders. Plus one means identical, minus one means exactly reversed, zero means unrelated.

One group goes the other way. The six passive dividend index funds show +0.52, but they yield between 2.3% and 3.5% and six is not a sample.

Is that circular? Partly

Partly, and we'd rather say so than have you find it.

Coverage divides by yield, so raise a fund's yield without raising its total return and its coverage score falls. The scale also pays for size and low fees, and big cheap passive funds win both whatever they yield. We built this scale to ask whether income is earned or manufactured, so it's no shock that it marks down products where the income is manufactured. A correlation between yield and our own score is partly a readout of our own design. We wouldn't offer the −0.71 as proof of anything about the market.

Three things in the table are not built in.

The stocks. Yield earns up to 15 points there, and the rank correlation is still −0.50. Whatever the other factors measure, in aggregate it outweighs the yield bonus.

Facts that never pass through our scoring. Among the 26 funds, higher yield goes with higher fees: a rank correlation of +0.47. Among the 27 stocks and REITs, higher yield goes with a worse year-to-date price change: −0.76. The second is mostly arithmetic, since yield is the payout divided by price and a falling price raises it. That's the first sign on the yield-trap checklist, measured across a whole universe. The biggest yields in this market are mostly price collapses, not generosity.

Evidence outside the table. The scale isn't a market experiment, but total returns are. ZWB against ZEB is the same six banks with and without a covered-call overlay, and the overlay cost about 3.8 points a year over a decade. VDY against HDIV put a 3% fund up against a 10% one over the past year, and the 3% fund returned roughly twice as much. Those numbers owe nothing to our scoring.

The two biggest stock yields are two cuts

The highest-yielding stock on the table is Allied Properties at 17.87%, rated SELL at 43. The second is Telus at 11.66%, rated SELL at 48. Allied is down about 71% this year and Telus about 31%, and both have just cut.

Telus cut its quarterly dividend by about 55% this year, from $0.4184 to $0.1875, starting with the October 1 payment. The 11.66% on the table is a trailing figure: three quarters at the old rate and one at the new, over a $12.37 unit price. On the current payout of $0.75 a year, the yield is about 6.1%.

Allied went further. On October 28 it announced a second distribution cut, this time 90%, to $0.006 a unit a month starting in November. The 17.87% is the declared $0.72 a year divided by a $4.03 unit price. On the new rate it's under 2%.

We wrote about Allied's first cut in August and called the new payout covered, on management's projected cash flow. The stricter measure, AFFO, said otherwise, and so did our scale, which already had Allied at SELL. The post now carries a correction.

Both yields on the table are rear-view mirrors. A yield that far above its neighbours is usually the market telling you it doesn't believe the payout. Both times, the company eventually agreed.

What this doesn't show

It isn't a sample. We chose this universe, and 21 of the 28 funds are covered-call or enhanced-yield because that's the corner of the market we set out to examine.

It's a snapshot. One night's batch. Scores and yields move, and we'll rerun this each quarter.

Three tickers have no yield on file. Two are funds launched in May and one is a split-share corporation, so they're out of every correlation above.

The top of the scale is crowded. VDY, XEI, ZDV and ZEB all score 95, which means the scale can't separate them.

The covered-call cohort sits under the BUY line. None of the 21 covered-call or enhanced-yield funds earns a BUY, and the best scores 75. That's either the thesis working or a scale that's hard on the category, and both readings are fair. We haven't tuned it to hand the category a BUY for appearances' sake.

Read it yourself

Open the research page, sort by yield, then sort by score. The scatter chart plots yield across and score up, and the bottom-right corner, high yield and low score, is the part worth a second look. Every ticker links to its own page.

If you screen by yield, you're fishing in the part of this pond where nothing earned a BUY. The yield column isn't wrong. It's the one number in the table that tells you what already happened. Read it last. Start with whether the payout is earned, what it costs to collect, and what happened to the capital underneath, the same questions we put to every fund and stock we cover.

See your own portfolio's health score in under a minute.
Get started free →